17 January 2013

Harry Potter HFriday - Week the Third



Hey my favorite internet people!



I had A Thing to do involving family and stuff. But I read ALL your posts last week and chortled so much that my mom made me read some of them out loud, which was embarrassing because she caved and asked right about the time you all were making inappropriate comments about wizard pokers or some such. So good job making me feel like a teenager again!

Suffice to say I agree mightily with ALL of your quibbles and questions and queries and conundrums, especially the ones about wizard sewage and JK's rather fluid relationship with currency.

And here we are at the end of the book, and oh, JK. I am so pleased that you grew as a writer even though we have to get through Chamber of Secrets before the Good Stuff can happen.And while the first half was all fun and games and getting shut in the cupboard under the stairs for shit you didn't do, the second half is more OMG Harry has NO PARENTS and has never had Christmas presents and is probably a serial killer based on his upbringing. You know who else besides the Dursleys locked people in dark spaces for imagined sins?

This guy.
And we all know how Jodie Foster turned out. (On second thought, keep on keepin' on, Harry. She's pretty awesome and you wouldn't look like Jennifer Garner in drag. *sob*)

But back to the point I was trying to make, which is that this book is all about Harry finding his true home in the wizarding world. And gets an invisibility cloak like it's NBD, because he's Harry Potter. Speaking of which, WHERE did James and Lily get all this super-rare awesome shit and wizard dollars? How did they get rich? Not fighting the dark forces because Wizard England is not like Jane Austen England where captains got a portion of the spoils of war (where is my Temeraire movie, Hollywood? Dragons, costumes, ships! Get on that. ::glare::).

I particularly like the moment when MacGonagall says she couldn't looks Snape in the face after Gryffindor's loss to Slytherin the year before. And also the moment where Hermione is being such a snot about the levitating spell

Pretty sure I was like this as a kid. Pretty sure sometimes I still am.
But then it's the thing Ron remembers when push comes to shoving a wand up a troll's nose.  Awwww.

And there was the Mirror of Erised and the Christmas flute and Harry learning chess from Ron and possibly my favorite moment in the WHOLE SERIES is when Hermione loses her shit, goes full Muggle and shrieks that there isn't any wood to start a fire and Ron is all, "You're a WITCH!"



9.5 out of 11 Illegal Dragon Eggs. Onward!!

Comments (28)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I was/am Hermione - but I since I basically live on the internets I just wait 5 minutes before posting my crazy message about incorrect spelling, history, film theory. At least, I try to do that - I succeed maybe 4 out of 5 times.

I'm fairly sure that gold is from James' parents - because I feel like there's a mention of them being fairly wealthy at one point and they died prior to Harry's birth, so hello inheritance! But also, maybe when his parents died and left him to grow up with spiders and horrible muggles, everyone in the order chipped in a little so he'd actually have something when he hit Hogwarts age? Perhaps?
3 replies · active 636 weeks ago
I looooooved the 'YOU'RE A WITCH' bit! Love love love love loved it! Awww, poor Hermione losing her shit when things get intense.

I enjoyed reading this SO much that I'm almost scared to continue because this is basically my least favourite book (maybe) so I MIGHT EXPLODE AS THINGS HEAT UP! It will be worth it.
Hermione and the leviosa spell. That was her at peak of insufferablity. Though clearly that smugness helped Ron really learn the spell so I guess it works.

I'm having so much fun already but yeah, I can't wait to be done with Chamber and then get ready for the REAL fun.
2 replies · active 636 weeks ago
HEHE-ING LIZARD

Also the thing that bugs me that I forgot to mention in my post is that Ron's all "Oh yeah, an invisibility cloak" but ISN'T IT THE ONLY ONE EVER AND BASICALLY A MYTH? So how does that work? JK, please explain this (she probs already has, knowing the HP fandom).

ALSO, Hannibal Lecter did not do this. I don't think. Did he? I really don't think so. Even Buffalo Bill didn't think people were sinful; he just wanted a flesh coat made from fat ladies.

p.s. I have a lot of Chamber of Secrets feelings and we will hash out how it is awesome next week.
9 replies · active 636 weeks ago
Lol, I like that bit about the wood too. Because she's only known she's magical for less than a year so of course her Muggle instincts would kick in in a crisis!
LOVE this. And yeah, I'm like Hermione in that obnoxious, "let me help you pronounce/spell things correctly" way. Now I only try to do it with family and not, say, with strangers or coworkers or interwebs peoples.
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
I am also an IRL Hermione. I went as her for Halloween one year and carried a wooden knitting needle as a wand. Yeah.

It is kind of strange that Harry never questions anything about his parents' families. I mean, do we even know what his grandparents' names are?

And I assume that Lily and James never really had careers, right? They graduated and the wizarding world was in chaos, so they joined the Order of the Phoenix and then went into hiding soon, too. JKR seriously needs to write a prequel about them.
1 reply · active 636 weeks ago
HAHAHA I love that you mentioned the part where Hermione just loses it. It's a funny reminder that Hermione may be a know it all, but can 'short-circuit' every once in a while :)
'goes full Muggle' = LOOOOL.
Yay, you're back! I was wondering where your post (from last week) was! ;)

The part where Hermione loses her shit is one of my favorite parts too!
Love it when Hermione forgets that she's top-witch - we so rarely see her lose her cool.

I'm so anxious to get through CoS and get to the bigger books. Although I'm enjoying reading it more than I remember. Probably because HARRY POTTER! WOO!
Where did Harry get all that money? And why did they leave stuff for him at Hogwarts? I guess it would be a little complicated if he didn't have any money, but why do they need money? ALL THE QUESTIONS!

I'm really excited to read after book two, since this is my first time.

Post a new comment

Comments by