21 August 2013

Eleanor and Park - Rainbow Rowell



I read this entirely in one day during the Mini Readathon at the beginning of July (it was great, we'll do another one, hurrah for permission to read and eat all day!).  My justification for this being "mini" was that it is about teenagers, who are basically mini-humans in mind if not in body. And while, yes, that is technically true, oh lord.

Ladies, you know how sometimes you're like, "WHY am I sobbing at this? What is going ON? How do I FEEL SO MUCH RIGHT NOW?!?" and then two days later your least favorite aunt comes to visit and you're like, "oh. Maybe I won't die alone and pathetic and be eaten by wild dogs after all. Bring me the chocolate and ibuprofen, feline companion!" 

No.

Those first few days of feeeeeeels are not the ideal time to read Eleanor & Park, people, because Eleanor & Park is a book about... 


Ok, here's the thing. I got into a Twitter discussion with Rainbow Rowell last night about the Ramona books by Beverly Cleary, and I said that the Ramona books are ABOUT Ramona, but Judy Blume's books are ABOUT growing up, and that is why Ramona sticks with us ladies of a certain age: because she is a real kid with a real range of kid problems. She's also the reason I can't look at a crop of Shirley Temple curls without wanting to boing them.

Which brings me back to Eleanor & Park, and what this book is ABOUT. The title characters are complete, which I really liked and which is surprisingly rare for most books - I was going to say YA books, but let's be honest: characterization is not currently in style in fiction, is it? 



But Eleanor and Park are not only well-defined and realized, they're also genuine teenagers. They do stupid shit, they think stupid things, they get stuff wrong, they're just trying to survive being teens, which is - as you may remember - HARD ENOUGH. But wrapped in all of this is Eleanor's family, which is broke and broken in a way that made me uncomfortable because I grew up poor and broken but not the same kind, so I empathized but also felt weird about my empathy because the shit that happened to me when I was a kid is nothing compared to what she is going through. Empathy is an odd thing.

So, Tika, what is this book about? You got all excitable about telling us and then went off on a tangent.

Well, my dear reader, first of all you cannot be surprised that such a thing would happen. And secondly, Eleanor & Park is a book about growing up and first love and whimsy and the awkwardness of being a teenager and parenting and preconceived notions and a definite hint of pride and prejudice (the emotions, not the book). It made my heart sore, and soar, and I had to stop a few times to ugly cry - sometimes for Eleanor and sometimes for Park.

It's a book teachers of high school students should read to remind them of what it's like to be the beings they're trying to connect to, and that's about the highest praise I can think of.


10.5 of 11 Mix Tapes from the Radio

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
RAINBOW ROLL

I need to reread this, because I LIKED it, but I think I would like it more on a second go-through. But yeah, totally correct on fully realized characters not being a big thing lately. Which is the worstttttt because who cares about anything else in books? STUPID PEOPLE THAT'S WHO.
1 reply · active 606 weeks ago
YEA. Also stupid: people who don't like high-context humor. Or puns.
All of this is the truest so nice worrrrk reviewing things, Tika! (Is it bad that I thought you were talking about an actual aunt up there? It definitely is. I GOT THERE EVENTUALLY.)

Characterisation is due a comeback, I reckon. We should do something about that.
2 replies · active 605 weeks ago
Ahahha! What euphemisms do you Brits use? That's hilarious. :)
I ALSO THOUGHT THIS. I was like, "Oh, Tika must REALLY dislike that aunt if seeing her makes her realize that she just wants to be alone with her cat who won't fetch her things."
"It made my heart sore, and soar" Yes and YES. This review is spot on and especially about the whole fully realized character thing. Perhaps some other authors could take note a write some teenagers that actually seem like teenagers and not super witty, amazing, beautiful people that happen to go to high school.
2 replies · active 606 weeks ago
ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT JOHN GREEN, Alley? ::side-eye::
Well not JUST him. But he's sort of their leader. Even if I like the wittier-than-real-life people it doesn't mean I'm not eye-rolling
I've been waiting for your review of this one! I loved Eleanor&Park with very deep feels and then I pressed it into the hands of my husband who, for very good reasons, is generally not enamored of the YA genre. But as soon as he reads this he will love it, too.

Sore and Soar. I like what you did there.

This is by far the most substantive of Rainbow Roll's (can't think of her any other way now, thx) three books. I also liked it the most, which is not always corollary.
2 replies · active 605 weeks ago
Oh yay, I'm so glad you loved it too! I keep thinking of little bits and pieces of it, like the juxtaposition of Eleanor thinking she's fat, and then Park sees her as a series of stacked hearts. How soul-meltingly lovely and sad and also wonderful. Maybe your esteemed husband will love this one because it's not *really* a YA genre book? It's just... a book about teenagers (sorta). I think it just being a book is BETTER in a lot of ways. And I agree that it's the most substantive and that I like it better than Attachments (which I liked a LOT but I'm glad I read it first). I haven't read Fangirl yet, but I WILL!

Homophones are fun. :D
it actually took me a second to realize you hadn't said "homophobes" and i was about to say something nasty. whew!

I've never read a book that better evoked what it's like to fall in love for the first time--how it feels emotionally, but also how it feels in a tactile way. the way eleanor describes holding hands with Park for the first time? Wow. And I think it captured that purity of first love (when it's mutual on both sides), with the real generosity that comes with discovering love, and that whole lack of game-playing that comes in later relationships.

No, this book is a true gem and a classic of the genre. Hey, maybe Alley should just use this book for her book-wedding-idea thingy.
Omg, rainbow roll. This review is spot-on and I loved it. But rainbow roll? You win the internet. Congrats.

Sigh, this book made me ugly cry and took me back to my high school days which were AWFUL and AWESOME all at once.
I just started this this morning and I love it so much already, although I'm being really careful to spread it out and not devour it in 20 minutes like I did with Attachments. My family have been asking me what I want for my birthday next month and i've been telling everyone to get me Fangirl, which means I'll either get 5 copies (not a bad thing at all) or none - because that's how my family work.

Also, I have to join Laura in the momentary confusion about who your least favourite aunt was. It's a euphemism we use here all the time and STILL I wondered why you thought of your aunts in terms of preference. haha
2 replies · active 605 weeks ago
My family is the same way! My mom, poor lovely woman, is the WORST. She gets me things like blenders or miniature boxes of watercolors, but I don't like smoothies and I don't paint! And then I don't get the paella pan or the book I asked for. So silly.
I just finished reading this last night and OMG MY HEART HURTS IN THE BEST WAY.
Your fantastic post caused me to look back through my texts to find the one where you angry-texted me about the feels you were feeling while reading this. *sigh* Good times.

P.S. Does Rainbow know that she is now, forever and always, to be known as Rainbow Roll?

Post a new comment

Comments by