23 October 2012

Code Name: Verity - Elizabeth Wein



One of the reasons I don't tend to read mysteries is that I like to talk about plot, and it's difficult to do so when one-third of a book is about "Lo, a mystery!" and the other two-thirds are about "Let's solve this (preferably with witty banter and possible sexytimes, a la Castle and Bones)!" And then one has to dance around the plot, not Giving It All Away, much like a great aunt warning you against sexytimes of your own while "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow" plays sadly in the background.

And while this book is not a mystery, it presents many of the same discussion difficulties that a mystery might.


This book is...

I want to talk about...

And then there's this other thing...


Well, there is ONE thing I want to talk about. This book is set in the 1940s in England (mostly), and it's written in the first-person, which means that the characters should speak as if they were in that time period. And if I am not very much mistaken - which I am not - the convention of speaking forcefully being expressed in ALL CAPS, shouty-internet style, is fairly recent.

I know that complaining about all-caps usage by an author makes me a huge hypocrite. Trust me, I'm aware.

But it bugged me.

Especially because I tend to read sentences in all caps in a very specific type of shouty style - probably due to the book blogging friends I hang out with - which looks very much like this:

"...SO EMBARRASSING..." (p.1)

BUT aside from that, this is a Very Good Book and you should all read it and if I go on much longer I will Give It All Away, which as we've all learned will lead only to singing sad doo-wop tunes in the shower.

The best accolade for this book I can give is this: I think Connie Willis, High Dame of Alternative WWII History, would like it.


9 of 11 Muppet Flails, Aviatrixes!



Comments (11)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I'm trying to think of how you would denote shouting in a way other than all caps, cos I totally agree that ALL CAPS = internet yelling, which is different than normal world yelling.

...Except for Owen Meany. He can speak in all caps and not sound internet shouty.
5 replies · active 649 weeks ago
Well, you could do like they did in the pre-Internet days and use descriptors! Or just not write sentences like "SO EMBARRASSING," in your 1940's period novel, because a) sentence fragment and they were fairly strict about that kind of writing back then, and 2) it's very 2012.

But I quibble. (How would one denote quibbling?)
Right, yes, descriptors.

We need a quibbling font. Like a sarcasm font. Which is also needed.
There's a sarcasm punctuation mark. We should start using it regularly.
Also, yes, Owen Meany! That guy...
Owen definitely did not sound internet shouty, but I sure heard his voice in a high pitched loud voice (not yelling though). Owen Meany was the best.
You're right - books based mostly on plot are tough to talk about without giving anything away! Little things like you mentioned (CAPS = YELLING) would totally bug me too.
Heh, perhaps there's an audio version of this book so readers can remain blissfully ignorant of ALL THE CAPS? ;)
1 reply · active 648 weeks ago
Hmmm, maybe? I bet the audiobook version would be pretty good, actually!
Loved this one, and yes, it's really hard to tell anything about it without ruining it. It was worth it though. I don't remember the all-caps bit, but I can see why that would bug you.

Post a new comment

Comments by