04 February 2014

BleakAlong: Post the First


Well, here we are in the first week of the #BleakAlong and I've managed to make it through ALL the reading!



This will not last, so I intend to celebrate while I can.

Okay, so far this book is about contrasts, yes? There's the excruciatingly obvious Mrs. Pardiggle vs. Mrs. Jellyby, whose husbands should absolutely have dinner together, Esther. And then there's Chetney Wold vs. Bleak House, and the different areas of London, and how the Chancery differs from the real world...

But there are some things I HAVE to talk to you about: are we established and all on board that Esther and Ada are as queer as a three-dollar bill? Poor Mr. Guppy and his awkward proposal.


GOOD; more on that later.

But first I want to talk about the wallpapers in this book. Ada's bedroom at Bleak House is full of flowered things - the wallpaper, the upholstery, everything. Is it because she is Virgin in this tale, Mr. Dickens? No need to whack us over the head with that one. Then there's Esther's room, with the hard working people on the walls, making hay and whatnot, because she'll be the housekeeper you see. Without any training I might add - Dickens, that's a stretch. But the description of the sitting room is what made me sit up (hah) and take notice. It's papered with birds. Birds, who represent freedom and innocence, but whose song - like the birds of the mad old lady at Crook's shop - is silenced, in the case of this room, forever.. Is this a hint to us that the Jarndyce judgement will never come down, or that it might not be everything it's cracked up to be once Chancery has its way?

Close readings are the best.
Are you as weirded out by Boythorn as I am? Alice pointed out that Bleak House predates The Woman in White, but it doesn't change the fact that I met Count Fosco first and therefore will never again fully trust a giant, overblown man who has a strange way with the beasts of the field. And I submit to you, my friends, that Wilkie thought there was something creepy about it too, which could be why the two characters resemble each other.

The exception that proves the rule.
There's so much stuff in here, you guys! We could do a week per chapter and I'd STILL fill up 2 pages of notes.


Comments (11)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
"Without any training I might add - Dickens, that's a stretch." I kind of assumed she'd gotten that kind of training at her school. Like, since they were also like "Take control of the small children!" they could just be like 'And here's how you can order dinner and manage the books and so forth." Since she seems totally chill with it.

TOTALLY impressed by your birdy wallpaper observation. And also, yeah, could totally do one chapter a post. This book is so damn dense. But in a reeeeadable way.
Oh man, your wallpaper analysis. Good stuff. This is why I love our readalongs because I am spending my time just giggling at Mr. Guppy and his fancy neckerchief and awkward proposals.

"I met Count Fosco first and therefore will never again fully trust a giant, overblown man who has a strange way with the beasts of the field. " Ahahaha yes, I did get Fosco flashbacks here. But this guy seems so friendly (at least to us, not so much to that guy that PROBABLY ACCIDENTALLY gave him the wrong directions).
1 reply · active 581 weeks ago
(Or to his neighbor, the good Sir Lucifer!!) (bahahahhaha)
Damn, I forgot the wallpaper in my totally academic analysis of how birds are sorta significant in this book!
And Count Fosco! Now I finally know why I kept having Woman in White flashbacks all the time.
Also, Mr Guppy deserves a facepalm.
Look at how ANALYZY you're getting with the bits and pieces. I'm impressed.

It's affirming to me that we're all having Woman in White flashbacks as we read this. It makes me really, super glad we read that one first, even if it's technically in the wrong order, chronologically. Although, I do think Boythorn is less creepy than Fosco was, even in the beginning when I wanted to like Fosco. He has more of a booming boyishness about him. Like he never grew out of the mind-set he had when he first saved John Jarndyce from bullies in the school yard. So he's basically that one jock who is still a jock when you see him at the 20-year high school reunion, and instead of being sad it's kind of endearing. SO FAR. I could change my mind very soon.
You have very smart and analytical things to say and now I feel like my flapping at how gay Esther is (very gay) was foolish... Nah, I stand by that.

Poor, POOR Mr Guppy! I did feel for him, truly. Bless.
1 reply · active 581 weeks ago
The ONLY reason I didn't wax rhapsodic about Esther/Ada is that I knew I could trust you guys to do it for me this week!! Don't worry. Next week I'll take up the gauntlet or the torch or whatever.

Poor Guppy. What a codfish.
Minnesota Girlfriend's avatar

Minnesota Girlfriend · 581 weeks ago

I am really glad you mentioned Esther's lack of housekeeping training, because as I was trucking through the endless snowfields of Wisconsin (punctuated periodically by a store sign simply stating "CHEESE") and listening to this on audiobook, I kept wondering if I'd missed the chapter where Esther is taught to balance a budget. Then I told myself that this must be some Victorian thing I just don't know about, not having A Proper Book Blog. So I'm really glad you mentioned it.

I think your wallpaper commentary is brilliant. But of course everyone else has said so as well. So *high five*
The highest of Disney spoof fives for finishing the reading. A tip o' the cap to you. Also, please allow me to join in the gathering slow clap with the others here in response to your wallpaper analysis. Because, damn.

Esther and Ada! They will keep me reading.
Appreciate it pertaining to details. Acquire HIGH DEFINITION Wall papers without cost throughout Premium quality Promises, Pc Wall papers with regard to Widescreen, Fullscreen, Hd, Phone wall papers Regarding Apple mackintosh!
These include virtually all incredible HIGH-DEFINITION retaining wall reports. I'm keen on this kind of genuinely desirable pictures. Anyone can an excellent job. Provide cheers regarding talking over.

Post a new comment

Comments by