14 November 2013

The Divergent Series - Veronica Roth



Have we talked about these books before? I feel like I did, but it may have been in gchat and goodreads status updates.

I am so on top of things.


Lately it seems that a lot of books that I don't think are super-great are being turned into movies. There are lots of reasons for this, not the least of which is that teenagers aren't generally known for their nuanced taste but are known for disposable income and getting obsessed with seeing movies in the theater multiple times.

The Veronica Roth trilogy has been touted as the "next Hunger Games," among other things, which I suppose is better than being the next Twilight.

I've read all three of these series, and I am here to tell you in no uncertain terms that none of them stands up to some of the other, lesser-known YA authors available (thinking of you, Catherynne Valente and Rainbow Rowell). The first Hunger Games was interesting, but it lost me in book 2, aka The Hunger Games 2: In Case You Missed It The First Time, Now With Better Press! In the Divergent series, I liked book 2 better than book 1, but the third book spent approximately 400 pages talking about how segregating people based on genetics is not a good way to structure a society, which if you paid even the least bit of attention to the History of the 20th Century, you ALREADY KNOW.

The hashtag for Allegiant was full of sobbing and hand-wringing and OMG'ing, so being easily peer-pressured I slogged on to the end and while yes, there was a moment that made my eyes prickle and I was impressed a bit by The Choice Roth Made, it wasn't worth the whole 1500 pages to get there.

Most of what I got out of the series was that I'd like to zip-line off of the Sears Tower, please.

Let's not discuss Twilight. Or Bella.



4.5 of 11 Absurd Post-Apocalyptic Premises, plus one for avoiding the Love Triangle Trap.
Total: 5.5.

Comments (8)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I got approximately 100 pages in to the first book, where they'd finished climbing the Ferris wheel in this supposed VERY STRESSFUL and, like, thrilling scene, and I just...yawned. Life's too short for the Next Big Teen Book To Inspire The Next Big Teen Movie!
I've been trying to decide whether to read this book because obvs I'm seeing the film because, Kate Winslet. I don't really need a new YA series buuut maybe I should. Help, in other words, is it even worth the library lend?
"which if you paid even the least bit of attention to the History of the 20th Century, you ALREADY KNOW."

Ahahaha

Ugh. Why did this make me kind of finally want to read this series? I've avoided it so well. SIGH.
1 reply · active 593 weeks ago
The lackluster reviews always seem to get you. See: Finnegans Wake.
I have literally ZERO desire to read this series. And I'm concerned it's because I'm moderately snobbish about YA. But I'm not trying very hard to fix that, really. *thinks about it* Nope.
I totally judged this series by the YA-covers... but my obsessive need to read books and beat it to the movie theater is a game-changer. And yes, thank you for pointing out that YA-prevalent Love Triangle Trap - at least I can read this in peace!
I actually had fun with this book and read it on an airplane last month. I thought the idea behind it was fairly interesting and it made me wonder what it would be like to read the same story for adults, with a greater level of sophistication and nuance that that implies. Lots of YA dystopian books make me wonder that, actually.

I will probably, eventually read the other two in the series but I'm in no rush to do so. I am, however, rather eager to see the movie because of Kate Winslet, as Kayleigh already pointed out.
Acquisition and education of the different and variant subjects is at the foundation and ebb of the constructive nature the structures are very precious and valuable for the inculcation and infliction of the studies. Its material is vital and pivotal.

Post a new comment

Comments by