06 June 2013

Harry Potter HFriday -Part the Penultimate


And we’re back after the excitement that SOME of us enjoyed at BEA, and the excitement that the REST of us shared in the privacy of our own homes, far away from the City that Smells Like the Subway. And despite two whole weeks between posts, I still couldn’t bring myself to read this week’s chapters until last night because every time I cracked this book open and saw Xenophilius's name, it made me want to 
I KNOW he just loves his daughter. SIGH.
And then I cried - before I even started reading whoamIevenanymore - because despite all of our declarations about how fun this readalong would be and how much we were looking forward to the nostalgia of yesteryear and getting our veritable Hogwarts letters in January, it turns out this readalong is really all about crying ahead of time now that we are older and wiser and know what’s going to happen.

But before we get into that, let’s take a moment to make fun of Megs, who chastised us last week for moaning about how the camping, it is so long, and yet it only lasted a little while! Well, it DID, in last week’s chapters. But then they camp some more, for LO!, these MANY MONTHS, because Ron comes back around New Years and then suddenly it is MARCH. There is a point at which “camping” becomes “just living in the woods,” and you have crossed that point, Miss Jo. These kids have been out in the elements since school started in September!

That is a long-ass time to be sleeping in a tent, you guys.

Then Dobby shows up in the cellar and I started sniffling a little even though he kind of makes me crazy in the entire rest of the series. And then stupid BELLATRIX and her desire for Lord Voldemort’s wand, if you know what I’m saying – which I know you do because we’re all dirty birds over here – with her stupid knife and at this point I’ve forgotten whose actual wand is whose, but apparently Harry has a pocketful of them (and his homies do too).

Laid back.
Harry digs the grave himself and it's very contemplative and at one moment he thinks, "am I meant to know but not to seek?" and that is some mythic hero shit right there. And then he carves the letters into Dobby's headstone (it goes over where his head goes, get it??) and I think, oh, that's where those little wrinkly stains on this page came from. They are the ghosts of tears from 2007.

They bungle the stealing-from-Gringott's thing beautifully, don't they? And the apparate to Hogsmeade like idiots. It's almost like they're teenagers. Then there's Aberforth, at whom we have been sniggering this whole time and he turns out to have a secret pain and UGH that is just the worst way to make me feel guilty, JK.

The whose-wand-is-whose thing is always a little weird to me – I mean, if your wand is made of birch and mine is black walnut, then obviously I’m not going to mistake yours for mine. But would I mistake yours for someone else’s light-colored wand? Probably, because who pays that much attention to someone else's wand? And speaking of wands, I’m pretty sure I’d study wandlore if I were a witch. It’s so hazy and mysterious and somehow scholarly but also it would appeal to my inner Goth, who EXISTS, dammit! I was cool in the 90’s!

I was not cool in the 90's.


Comments (13)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I'm kind of getting choked up today because we all keep pointing out that next week is the last week, and I'm sad because this will be over and ALSO because I know what's coming and GAH WEEP.

The wandlore stuff is so so interesting. I had forgotten a LOT of it, so I kept going 'oooh! OOOOH!' in my brain because that's how cool I am :)
The best thing about Harry Potter is that amongst their fantastic plans or rescue scenes they do some of the dumbest shit imaginable. Because they're kids. And even though they think they're all adult and responsible and clever it doesn't occur to them that apparating straight into Hogsmeade is a bad idea, or that maybe they shouldn't yell each other's name out in a graveyard when they're wearing disguises.

I don't know what to make of Harry having a pocket full of wands - can I sexualise that, or does it just make everything super weird and creepy all of a sudden?!
Hahaha, I would totally study wandlore. I don't understand why Hermione never did! Maybe it was too fuzzy a branch of study for her. I do remember when I read this book for the first time, I felt sort of annoyed that JKR didn't include more wand stuff in earlier books -- like, maybe just mention the "Wand of elder, never prosper" thing that Ron brings up, or talk about wands transferring their allegiance. Just a little bit! So that when we got to the seventh book, we'd already know that was an available thing to have happen. Wouldn't that have been better?

There are no ghost tears in my book from 2007. I think I get more and more heartless the later I stay up at night. I didn't cry at all the first time when Dobby died. I gasped extravagantly and when my sister said WHAT WHAT WHAT STOP GASPING (because I was a little farther along than she was), I said, "It's okay! It's not as bad as it could be!" Part of me is deeply ashamed of this, but part of me kind of sticks to it. It's bad, but it's not as bad as it could be.
1 reply · active 616 weeks ago
YES to the hints about wand lore earlier in the series. This clearly would have been better. Only saying that the wand chooses the wizard doesn't give us enough context.

I'm the opposite of you--the later at night it is, the more I sob with abandon.
I am so happy that I don't remember this book that well. I remember enough so that I know roughly when the SUPER SAD parts are coming, so they don't blindside me. But I don't remember them enough to preemptively start bawling.

"There is a point at which “camping” becomes “just living in the woods,” and you have crossed that point, Miss Jo" bahaha yes, true. Although keep in mind they have a wizarding tent that includes a stove and actual beds. This is like RV camping instead of really roughing it.

I would study wandlore I'm still a bit fuzzy on the whole "wand allegiance thing" especially when it comes to just buying a new one.
1 reply · active 616 weeks ago
I remember ONLY the deaths in this book and roughly where they land, so when someone's last scene begins, it's all over for me. I'm going soft.

RV camping is still camping. Also, where does their food come from? Fourth law of mumble mumble thingy... they can't just magic it up, right?

Wand allegiance makes no sense to me. I would ALSO like this explained; I suppose that if your wand is busted, its allegiance to you ends so another wand is free to choose you. But then Ollivander just sends Luna a new wand (I got excited and read a little ahead), so he clearly MADE it for her, otherwise the wand-wizard choosing process from book 1 would have been so much shorter. "ACCIO HARRY'S WAND!" aaaand done.
I HAVE AN INNER GOTH MAYBE THIS IS WHY WE'RE FRIENDS

It's just buried deep down because I am so SMILEY.

Also, I need to read all this shit. I'm so far behind. But I've been reading about women's suffrage and that is IMPORTANT. Also BEA tailgating. Which you should come to next time. Or when it's in Chicago in 2015, 'cause that's just easier.
1 reply · active 616 weeks ago
INSIDE WE ARE CRYING BLACK EYELINER-LACED TEARS. Deep, deep inside.
Wand lore IS awesome and I would totally be studying it with you.

I am completely torn up for Xeno this time around. I could clearly never be a spy because I'm not sure I could give preference to the greater good when my most-loved and only living relative were in the hands of the most sadistic bastards on earth and I could get her back if I betrayed my principles. the shades of this book become grayer with every reading of it that I do, and that's part of JKR's brilliance, I think.

Let's plan now for BEA 2015 and we will have the most awesome tailgating. Which means I'll have to spend a week in chicago because I will have actual work that needs to be done but I won't want to miss the tailgating and milkshakes, etc.
2 replies · active 616 weeks ago
Excellent. We will make ALL the wand puns as wandlore studiers and giggle all the time. People will look at us like... well, probably like the ret of the Serious Book Blogging World looks at us now. So we're used to it!

Yea, I'd be a terrible spy for the same reasons. I mean, even HRH can't be mad at him once they realize that Luna has been captured, right? AGH. Poor, poor man.

And YES to Chicago 2015.
We can all be failed spies together! I feel so, so bad for Xenophilius at that part -- he's trying to save his daughter but has to betray everything be believes in to do so... Ugh, worst situation ever. I'm just glad that Hermione was smart enough to find a way for the Death Eaters to see Harry before they peaced out of there.
That Aberforth bit is rough. Poor Ariana! Poor everybody! And also, while we're pooring, poor Narcissa and Draco being "punished" by big V after the cellar escape. Agh, Draco.
Heyyyyyy now. You're making fun of me, and I'm not exactly sure why...which is my LEAST favorite being-made-fun-of scenario. Maybe they DID camp forever, but it didn't FEEL like forever. Because we were't always just sitting around with them, y'know? There were other things afoot to keep us occupied. I STAND BY MY EARLIER RULING.

Post a new comment

Comments by